Problem No rank
Prot paladin is not ranked as a tank. Not the first time actually.

Most probably because he didn’t actually realy tank.
When you look at the damages taken compared to the blood DK, you can actually think there is just one tank and an other guy in tank spe doing tourism around the place (no offense to the paladin prot meant, that’s probably just a result of the strat you use)

Yeah, the damage taken by paladin is lower, but!
If you look at the CASTS taken, it’s the same. So both tanks were doing the same duty. I think lower damage intake is due to strong paladin’s AM.
It seems it’s just tank uptime issue, as there’s few enemies that needs to be actually tanked during this encounter.

Other day the bdk not being ranked =)