Logs showing suspicious activity

Our guild got world buffs and tried to clear MC as fast as we could for the first time. However, many of our DPS have * next to them so we are not appearing on the rankings. Anyone else having trouble with this?

https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/jZYa1cxLFGzMgCtD

Note the cutoff for P1/P2 was 3am EST because of the new Darkmoon Faire appearing on Monday. All ranks now are going into a new P3 partition.